When it comes to your home and family, nothing protects them as effectively as a stable roof. However, with such a tough job to handle your roof will start to show signs of damage and wear and tear. When that time comes, knowing which one you should go with between a roof repair vs replacement can help your roof continue to protect your home and family with ease. In this blog, we are going to help you decide which of the two roof services, a repair or replacement, you should get!

Difference Between a Roof Repair and Replacement
Before jumping into which roof services you should look for, it’s important to understand the difference between a roof repair and a replacement.

  • Roof Repair: Roof repair services mainly involve minor roof repairs such as patching a small hole or replacing a few worn-out shingles , reflashing a chimney or skylight. This option tends to be the more cost-effective choice between the two options.
  • Roof Replacement: A roof replacement is more complicated and involves removing the existing roofing material, an inspection of the inspection of the underside of the roof sheeting or decking for organic growth and delamination, and then an installation of new roofing materials. This option will be more expensive and time-consuming.

Repair or Replace Roof Considerations
There are a few factors you need to consider when it’s time to decide if you should look for roof repair services or roof replacement services.

  • Age of Your Roof: The first factor you need to consider is the age of your roof. Most roofs have an average lifespan of 18-22 years. If your roof is near this range, it may be time to consider replacing it, but if it’s much less than that then roof repair services should be enough.
  • How Damaged is Your Roof: Take note of how damaged your roof is. If you live in an area that is prone to harsh weather conditions, then your roof will likely be more damaged. The extent of the damage will determine if you should get a roof repair vs replacement.
  • Cost Considerations: You must take your current financial situation into consideration. You can start by creating a budget and then estimate roofing costs by looking into roof repair prices and replacement prices.
  • Plans for Your Home: The last factor to consider is how long you plan on staying at your current home. If it’s a short-term living space, then minor roof repairs should get you through, but if it’s a long-term home then a replacement will be a better investment.

So, Should You Get a Roof Repair or Replacement?
As the condition of a roof will vary from house to house, taking note of all the above factors will help you determine if you need a residential roof repair or complete replacement.

Get a Repair If:

  • Your roof is relatively new.
  • It doesn’t have major damages.
  • It’s the only option within your budget.
  • You plan on finding a new place to live soon.

Get a Replacement If:

  • It was last replaced 18-22 years ago or more.
  • Your roof is leaking from multiple places
  • All your roofing materials are nearly worn out.
  • You have the funds for it.
  • Your current home is going to be your forever home.

Seeking Professional Consultation
Determining if you should get a roof repair vs replacement can be tricky as there are a lot of outlier cases that can change the choice. For instance, if your roof is over 25 years old but has been well-maintained it can still get by with minor roof repairs. Another example is if your roof is brand new but suffered major damages or wasn’t installed correctly, it may need to be replaced sooner. To help you make the right decision, it would be best to consult with a professional roofing company. They have the ability to figure out what exactly your roof needs so you don’t have to make guesses.

Pacific West Roofing is here to help you make the right decisions when it comes to your roof. With over four decades of experience, we provide top-tier residential roofing services and commercial roofing services. Feel free to contact us here for your roofing needs.

Proudly serving various areas around the Portland Metro Area, here is a full list of our service areas.

Leave a comment


Winter is Coming: Prepare Your Roof

Portland Roofing Contractor Since 1980

CCB# 169414